First Team
Match Report | Rangers 1-1 Dundee United
23rd November 2024
Hibernian ran out comfortable victors this afternoon in what was for them a straightforward victory against a Dundee United side who looked susceptible every time the home side broke with intent. Goals by Derek Riordan and Chris Killen either side of an Alan Archibald own goal decided the result in only 33 minutes. With a minute remaining, substitute David Goodwillie became the SPL's youngest goalscorer with a simple finish into the net from a couple of yards.
Both sides showed two changes to the starting eleven from their games last weekend. For the home side, Chris Killen replaced Ivan Sproule, while Paul Dalgish - cup-tied last weekend - replaced Moscow-bound Garry O'Connor. Meanwhile, Craig Brewster welcomed back David McCracken after suspension, and the defender replaced David Robertson. Craig Samson was also given a start, as Derek Stillie had picked up an injury.
The home side started brightly, and capitalised on their advantage with a simple but well worked opening goal on six minutes. Kevin Thomson easily shrugged off the challenge of Fernandez inside the United half, before passing to Riordan on the corner of the area, who cut inside, and found an abundance of space to shoot low into the left hand corner of the goal from 18 yards.
Despite the home side's dominance, United could twice have drawn level against the run of play. In the 11th minute, Grant Brebner spotted Brown off his line, but with the keeper struggling to get back, his shot from fully 30 yards clipped the top of the crossbar on its way over. Ten minutes later, however, Mark Kerr had a far better chance to restore parity. After showing good reading of play to gain possession in midfield, Kerr played the ball out wide to Duff, whose cross was met with a cushioned knock down by Lee Miller. The ball dropped to Kerr, six yards out and with a clear sight of goal, but he could only slice his shot tamely wide.
Basic mistakes such as that have been punished regularly this season, and once again United were to regret this miss, when in the 25th minute, when Killen played a pass out to the left where Riordan checked, and crossed to the far post. With Samson beaten, and aware of a Hibs player behind him, Alan Archibald attempted to head over his own bar, but only succeeded in planting a header high into his own net.
Hibs' superiority in all departments was further demonstrated with a clinical third after 33 minutes. A long ball from his own half by Derek Riordan found Chris Killen, who took on Garry Kenneth and turned the United defender inside out with ease on the left side of the penalty area before firing a superb finish across Samson and in at the far post.
Half Time: Hibernian 3-0 Dundee United
Craig Brewster made two changes at half time, with Collin Samuel replacing David Fernandez, and David Robertson replacing Stuart Duff. It took less than two minutes for Robertson to make an impact, but it was only to get himself booked for a foul on Murphy.
United did show more promise going forward in the second half, with Robson's shot on the half volley turned behind by Brown, and McCracken flashing a free header wide from Robson's free kick. At the other end though, United still looked hugely fragile at the back, and a Hibs counter attack saw Dalglish's rasping shot from twenty yards tipped over by Samson.
After an inventive Hibs free kick had seen Glass's cross just evade Killen in front of goal, a free kick for the visitors was headed back into the danger area by Robson. David Robertson made a late run, but despite doing well to reach the ball, could only direct it wide.
Collin Samuel should have given United a consolation with a quarter of an hour left, after being left unmarked in the area to receive Robson's cross, but after controlling on his chest, the Trinidadian tried to dink the ball over Brown who stood up to easily block.
Samson did well to turn behind a close range Sproule shot with eight minutes remaining, after the winger had stolen in at the back post to meet Riordan's cross from the right, before David Goodwillie, on the pitch for less than three minutes, tapped in to become the SPL's youngest goalscorer after Samuel's cross had hit the bar, and Robertson had hit the post with the rebound.
Full Time: Hibernian 3-1 Dundee United
Summary: Although United showed more in the second half, it has to be remembered that the game was dead and buried long before half time. In the first half, Hibs looked by far the quicker side, and also were by far the hungrier and more skilful side.
Whilst United were guilty of missing chances, and should have levelled the game at 1-1, the scoreline was unfortunately less than a true reflection of the gulf in quality between the sides in terms of quick, composed, constructive and accurate passing.
Whilst some players had shown some quality while their side were in possession, Barry Robson and Grant Brebner for example, the United side are being far too easily dominated by their opponents at the moment, and hopefully the increased work levels in training will eventually pay off to rectify this.
Man of the Match: Over the course of the match, picking out a United player who had sufficiently impressed was a difficult task, for the reasons noted above. However, albeit on the pitch for a matter of minutes, the award goes to David Goodwillie for picking up the record for being youngest goalscorer in the SPL at the tender age of 16.
Teams:
Hibernian:
Simon Brown, Whittaker, Caldwell, Smith, Murphy, Stewart (Konde 56), Thomson, Glass, Dalglish (Sproule 61), Killen (Fletcher 75), Riordan.
Subs Not Used:
Malkowski (GK), Hogg, Konte, McCluskey.
Goals: Riordan (6), Archibald (og 25), Killen (33)
Booked: Killen
Dundee United:
Samson, McCracken, Kenneth, Archibald, Mair, Duff (Robertson 45), Brebner, Kerr, Robson, Miller (Goodwillie 86), Fernandez (Samuel 45).
Subs Not Used:
Gibson (GK), Abbot, Gardiner, McInnes.
Goal: Goodwillie (89)
Booked: Robertson, Robson, Kerr, Brebner
Referee: Brian Winter
Click here for the full report by Scott Simpson.
Both sides showed two changes to the starting eleven from their games last weekend. For the home side, Chris Killen replaced Ivan Sproule, while Paul Dalgish - cup-tied last weekend - replaced Moscow-bound Garry O'Connor. Meanwhile, Craig Brewster welcomed back David McCracken after suspension, and the defender replaced David Robertson. Craig Samson was also given a start, as Derek Stillie had picked up an injury.
The home side started brightly, and capitalised on their advantage with a simple but well worked opening goal on six minutes. Kevin Thomson easily shrugged off the challenge of Fernandez inside the United half, before passing to Riordan on the corner of the area, who cut inside, and found an abundance of space to shoot low into the left hand corner of the goal from 18 yards.
Despite the home side's dominance, United could twice have drawn level against the run of play. In the 11th minute, Grant Brebner spotted Brown off his line, but with the keeper struggling to get back, his shot from fully 30 yards clipped the top of the crossbar on its way over. Ten minutes later, however, Mark Kerr had a far better chance to restore parity. After showing good reading of play to gain possession in midfield, Kerr played the ball out wide to Duff, whose cross was met with a cushioned knock down by Lee Miller. The ball dropped to Kerr, six yards out and with a clear sight of goal, but he could only slice his shot tamely wide.
Basic mistakes such as that have been punished regularly this season, and once again United were to regret this miss, when in the 25th minute, when Killen played a pass out to the left where Riordan checked, and crossed to the far post. With Samson beaten, and aware of a Hibs player behind him, Alan Archibald attempted to head over his own bar, but only succeeded in planting a header high into his own net.
Hibs' superiority in all departments was further demonstrated with a clinical third after 33 minutes. A long ball from his own half by Derek Riordan found Chris Killen, who took on Garry Kenneth and turned the United defender inside out with ease on the left side of the penalty area before firing a superb finish across Samson and in at the far post.
Half Time: Hibernian 3-0 Dundee United
Craig Brewster made two changes at half time, with Collin Samuel replacing David Fernandez, and David Robertson replacing Stuart Duff. It took less than two minutes for Robertson to make an impact, but it was only to get himself booked for a foul on Murphy.
United did show more promise going forward in the second half, with Robson's shot on the half volley turned behind by Brown, and McCracken flashing a free header wide from Robson's free kick. At the other end though, United still looked hugely fragile at the back, and a Hibs counter attack saw Dalglish's rasping shot from twenty yards tipped over by Samson.
After an inventive Hibs free kick had seen Glass's cross just evade Killen in front of goal, a free kick for the visitors was headed back into the danger area by Robson. David Robertson made a late run, but despite doing well to reach the ball, could only direct it wide.
Collin Samuel should have given United a consolation with a quarter of an hour left, after being left unmarked in the area to receive Robson's cross, but after controlling on his chest, the Trinidadian tried to dink the ball over Brown who stood up to easily block.
Samson did well to turn behind a close range Sproule shot with eight minutes remaining, after the winger had stolen in at the back post to meet Riordan's cross from the right, before David Goodwillie, on the pitch for less than three minutes, tapped in to become the SPL's youngest goalscorer after Samuel's cross had hit the bar, and Robertson had hit the post with the rebound.
Full Time: Hibernian 3-1 Dundee United
Summary: Although United showed more in the second half, it has to be remembered that the game was dead and buried long before half time. In the first half, Hibs looked by far the quicker side, and also were by far the hungrier and more skilful side.
Whilst United were guilty of missing chances, and should have levelled the game at 1-1, the scoreline was unfortunately less than a true reflection of the gulf in quality between the sides in terms of quick, composed, constructive and accurate passing.
Whilst some players had shown some quality while their side were in possession, Barry Robson and Grant Brebner for example, the United side are being far too easily dominated by their opponents at the moment, and hopefully the increased work levels in training will eventually pay off to rectify this.
Man of the Match: Over the course of the match, picking out a United player who had sufficiently impressed was a difficult task, for the reasons noted above. However, albeit on the pitch for a matter of minutes, the award goes to David Goodwillie for picking up the record for being youngest goalscorer in the SPL at the tender age of 16.
Teams:
Hibernian:
Simon Brown, Whittaker, Caldwell, Smith, Murphy, Stewart (Konde 56), Thomson, Glass, Dalglish (Sproule 61), Killen (Fletcher 75), Riordan.
Subs Not Used:
Malkowski (GK), Hogg, Konte, McCluskey.
Goals: Riordan (6), Archibald (og 25), Killen (33)
Booked: Killen
Dundee United:
Samson, McCracken, Kenneth, Archibald, Mair, Duff (Robertson 45), Brebner, Kerr, Robson, Miller (Goodwillie 86), Fernandez (Samuel 45).
Subs Not Used:
Gibson (GK), Abbot, Gardiner, McInnes.
Goal: Goodwillie (89)
Booked: Robertson, Robson, Kerr, Brebner
Referee: Brian Winter
Click here for the full report by Scott Simpson.
