First Team
Match Report | Rangers 1-1 Dundee United
23rd November 2024
An unbelievable second half comeback by Aberdeen knocked United out of the Cup at the first hurdle. In a game completely dominated by United for the first hour, they had a comfortable two-goal lead at half time thanks to two David Fernandez efforts. But after Collin Samuel missed a header that should have put the game beyond the visitors, the fight back started. Two goals from Crawford and the winner from Barry Nicholson stole the tie for Aberdeen.
Gordon Chisholm handed a debut to on-loan Celt, Charles Mulgrew, who replaced the suspended Paul Ritchie. Also starting were the doubtful Collin Samuel and despite mounting speculation, Mark Wilson. Fellow injury concern Grant Brebner only managed a place on the bench. Aberdeen had two former United men in their line-up in the shape of Stevie Crawford and debutant Danny Griffin.
In a first half with chances a plenty, the visitors should have had the lead after 15 minutes. A Crawford shot was mishandled by Stillie but the United keeper made up for his error with a point blank save from Nicholson. The rebound fell to McNaughton who should have scored but he smashed the ball over. Ten minutes later the game was turned on its head. Samuel played in a great low cross and David Fernandez bravely headed home. A minute later the same two combined with Samuel playing in his strike partner and the Spaniard rolled the ball past the oncoming Langfield. It was so close to a first half hat-trick on the stroke of half time but an excellent free kick was superbly saved by the Dons keeper.
The second half started with a series of corners for the visitors but on the hour mark United should have put the game beyond Aberdeen. A Wilson free kick picked out Fernandez who saw his shot deflected for a corner. The corner was played short to Stuart Duff who picked out Samuel but the United forward headed wide from six yards. A minute later the tie was alive again when a mistake from Stillie was pounced on by Crawford and the former United man could not fail to score. Seven minutes later the game was level when Byrne picked out Crawford again and he made it 2-2. With both teams pressing for the winner it was the visitors who booked their place in the next round with ten minutes left. Crawford and Foster combined well to set up Barry Nicholson who slotted the ball past the helpless Stillie.
Summing Up - A sickner for United who played really well for an hour of the match and had a two goal lead that could easily have been more. In the end, the game could have gone either way but the United players must feel they threw away the tie.
Man of the match - David Fernandez for his two goals although Collin Samuel was also excellent. New boy, Charles Mulgrew also looked very solid at the back and possesses a dangerous left foot.
Teams:
United: Stillie, Wilson, McCracken, Archibald, Mulgrew, Kerr, McIntyre, Robson, Duff (Miller 82), Fernandez, Samuel
Subs not used : Samson, McInnes, Brebner, Kenneth
Aberdeen: Langfield, McNaughton, Anderson, Smith, Nicholson, Lovell (Mackie 59), Clark, Dempsey (Foster 46), Byrne, Crawford (Considine 84), Griffin
Subs not used Esson, Stewart
Referee: S Dougal
Attendance: 8218
Click here to read the full match report by Gareth Scott.
Gordon Chisholm handed a debut to on-loan Celt, Charles Mulgrew, who replaced the suspended Paul Ritchie. Also starting were the doubtful Collin Samuel and despite mounting speculation, Mark Wilson. Fellow injury concern Grant Brebner only managed a place on the bench. Aberdeen had two former United men in their line-up in the shape of Stevie Crawford and debutant Danny Griffin.
In a first half with chances a plenty, the visitors should have had the lead after 15 minutes. A Crawford shot was mishandled by Stillie but the United keeper made up for his error with a point blank save from Nicholson. The rebound fell to McNaughton who should have scored but he smashed the ball over. Ten minutes later the game was turned on its head. Samuel played in a great low cross and David Fernandez bravely headed home. A minute later the same two combined with Samuel playing in his strike partner and the Spaniard rolled the ball past the oncoming Langfield. It was so close to a first half hat-trick on the stroke of half time but an excellent free kick was superbly saved by the Dons keeper.
The second half started with a series of corners for the visitors but on the hour mark United should have put the game beyond Aberdeen. A Wilson free kick picked out Fernandez who saw his shot deflected for a corner. The corner was played short to Stuart Duff who picked out Samuel but the United forward headed wide from six yards. A minute later the tie was alive again when a mistake from Stillie was pounced on by Crawford and the former United man could not fail to score. Seven minutes later the game was level when Byrne picked out Crawford again and he made it 2-2. With both teams pressing for the winner it was the visitors who booked their place in the next round with ten minutes left. Crawford and Foster combined well to set up Barry Nicholson who slotted the ball past the helpless Stillie.
Summing Up - A sickner for United who played really well for an hour of the match and had a two goal lead that could easily have been more. In the end, the game could have gone either way but the United players must feel they threw away the tie.
Man of the match - David Fernandez for his two goals although Collin Samuel was also excellent. New boy, Charles Mulgrew also looked very solid at the back and possesses a dangerous left foot.
Teams:
United: Stillie, Wilson, McCracken, Archibald, Mulgrew, Kerr, McIntyre, Robson, Duff (Miller 82), Fernandez, Samuel
Subs not used : Samson, McInnes, Brebner, Kenneth
Aberdeen: Langfield, McNaughton, Anderson, Smith, Nicholson, Lovell (Mackie 59), Clark, Dempsey (Foster 46), Byrne, Crawford (Considine 84), Griffin
Subs not used Esson, Stewart
Referee: S Dougal
Attendance: 8218
Click here to read the full match report by Gareth Scott.
